Hague Convention Wrongful Removal Retention Appeals are a specialized area of family law. In today’s blog, International Academy of Family Lawyers (IAFL) member Lorne N MacLean KC explains the legal test applied in appeals from a “Hague Convention Return Order”. MacLean has successfully represented both sides of this emotional issue and his team has recently won two Hague return orders in the past few months.
Vancouver Hague Convention Wrongful Removal Retention Appeals
In Hague Convention Wrongful Removal Retention Appeals, our highest courts make it clear that there is no separate “Hague appeal test” equivalent to the RJR—MacDonald stay test. The British Columbia Court of Appeal applies the ordinary appellate standards of review:
-
Questions of law, including interpretation of the Hague Convention or the Family Law Act, are reviewed for correctness. (Laranjeira e Silva v. Virco, 2024 BCCA 164 (CanLII), [52]–[53])
-
Findings of fact, including evidence about intention, residence, risk, or acquiescence, are reviewed for palpable and overriding error. (Housen v. Nikolaisen, [2002] 2 SCR 235, 2002 SCC 33 (CanLII), [8]–[10]; Sampley v. Sampley, 2015 BCCA 113 (CanLII), [11])
-
Mixed questions of fact and law, such as applying the habitual-residence or Article 13 exception to the facts, are generally reviewed for palpable and overriding error, unless an extricable error of law or failure to apply the correct legal test is shown. (Housen v. Nikolaisen, [26]–[37]; Beri v. Sachdeva, 2026 BCCA 20 (CanLII), [30])
-
Thus, on an appeal from a Hague return order, the appellant must generally show either:
-
the judge applied the wrong legal test or interpreted the Convention incorrectly;
-
the judge failed to consider a required element of the Hague analysis; or
-
the factual findings contain a palpable and overriding error.
Vancouver Hague Habitual Residence Appeals Tel: 604 602 9000
For habitual residence specifically, the Court of Appeal reviews the legal framework for correctness but defers to the application judge’s factual application of that framework absent palpable and overriding error. Office of the Children’s Lawyer v. Balev, [2018] 1 SCR 398, 2018 SCC 16 (CanLII) describes the habitual-residence inquiry as fact-bound and requiring consideration of all relevant circumstances; Laranjeira e Silva v. Virco confirms that misapplying that framework can constitute a legal error reviewable for correctness. (Office of the Children’s Lawyer v. Balev, [38], [42]–[47]; Laranjeira e Silva v. Virco, [52]–[59])

Vancouver Hague Convention Wrongful Removal Retention Appeals -Grave Risk Tel: 604 602 9000
For an Article 13(b) grave-risk issue, whether the exception is established is generally treated as a factual, evidence-based determination. The appellant must show palpable and overriding error in the judge’s conclusion.
Our winning Hague Convention Wrongful Removal Retention Appeals team can help you on short notice. Deadlines apply, so don’t delay if you believe your child has been wrongfully removed or retained from their habitual residence.
